International conflict reporting
EN
Menu

Our Method

We assess specific claims and show how we reached each conclusion.

How to read the traffic light

Red · Insufficient evidence
The available evidence is insufficient to verify the claim. Red does not mean the claim is false.
Yellow · Conflicting evidence
Credible evidence conflicts or the conclusion remains weak. Disagreement alone is insufficient.
Green · Strong evidence
Independent evidence supports the claim.
FALSE

The available evidence refutes the specific claim. A denial by a party involved must be assessed against the evidence.

Each assessment applies to a specific claim and to the evidence available on the date shown. We weigh each item by how directly it addresses the claim, its provenance and methods, and the independent checks available. We assess the document in context. An organisation’s reputation is only one part of that context.

The rating describes the strength of the evidence for that claim. It does not extend to other claims or assign responsibility in general.

Use of AI

Artificial intelligence contributes to research, writing and translation. It is not a documentary source and does not replace checking evidence. We do not present generated text or images as firsthand testimony.

AI output is neither documentary evidence nor a guarantee of accuracy. Whoever conducts the research or fact check must carry out and record checks A and B on every source they use and state what remains unverified.

Source checks

Source checks

Each assistant performs and records both checks on the sources used in its own research and fact checks.

A · Source identity and provenance
Open the original and check its provenance, date, context and the exact passage cited. Record whether the original was accessible and identify any copy consulted.
B · What the source substantiates
Record exactly what the source establishes and its limits. Seek independent corroboration when needed and record gaps or reliance on the same material.

If a check is incomplete, record what remains unchecked and why.

Sources

Updates and corrections

Each assessment records the exact claim, the date, the reasoning, the evidence and its limits. New evidence can change an assessment. Corrections are dated, explain what changed and preserve the previous wording.

Correction history